2025年12月17日 星期三

What are distro-specific app, flatpak, snap, and appimage?

In the Linux world, there are distro-specific apps, flatpaks, snaps, and appimages.  A particular application may be built in any of these forms.


Distro-Specific Apps

  • They are applications packaged in formats tied to a specific Linux distribution, for example, .deb for Debian, Ubuntu, Linux Min, and .rpm for Fedora, openSUSE, Red Hat

  • Pros:

    • Seamless integration with the distro’s package manager.

    • Optimized for that system’s libraries and standards.

  • Cons:

    • Not portable across distros.

    • Developers must maintain multiple packages for different distros.


Flatpak

  • A universal packaging system that runs apps in a sandboxed  environment.

  • Key Features:

    • Uses runtimes (shared libraries) to reduce duplication.

    • Strong sandboxing for security.

    • Managed via flatpak command and Flathub repository.

  • Pros: Works across most Linux distros, good security isolation.

  • Cons: Larger disk usage, slower startup compared to native package


Snap

  • Developed by Canonical (Ubuntu’s parent company).

  • Key Features:

    • Self-contained packages with all dependencies.

    • Automatic updates via Snap Store.

    • Runs in a sandbox with confinement levels.

  • Pros:  Works across most Linux distros, Easy updates, wide adoption in Ubuntu ecosystem.

  • Cons: Slower startup, centralized control (Snap Store), less popular outside Ubuntu


AppImage

  • Portable application format — just download and run the file.

  • Key Features:

    • Single executable file containing the app and dependencies.

    • No installation required; works like a portable app on Windows.

  • Pros: Extremely simple, lightweight, no root access needed. Works across most Linux distros,

  • Cons: No built-in update mechanism (unless developer adds it), weaker sandboxing.


Which type of application to use?

  • Use distro-specific packages if you want tight integration with your Linux distribution.

  • Use Flatpak for cross-distro desktop apps with good sandboxing.

  • Use Snap if you’re in the Ubuntu ecosystem and want automatic updates.

  • Use AppImage for portable, no-install apps you can run anywhere.


Personal experience:

I found that distro-specific packages are easy to install but are prone to have bugs particularly after system updates. So I have used many flatpak applications, for example Smplayer, and Celluloid flatpaks.

For Acestream Player, I can only install  its snap form for viewing acestream videos. 


沒有留言:

張貼留言